V-TOP Tub Stopper 2 Pack Silicone Drain Plug Sinks Stopper Flat Suction Cover for Kitchen Bathroom and Laundry 6 inches (White&Blue)

Q: It’s not actually silicon. what should i do next?

There's a couple easy ways to test if it's silicone. Try applying a drop of silicone caulk to the clean surface. Give it about 4 hours to dry and then peel it off. Silicone caulk bonds strongly with silicone, not other rubber formulations. Second, you can try to dissolve it in acetone. Acetone eats rubber and most other plastics, but doesn't touch silicone.

Q: I ordered a two pack and only received one. Can you ship the other teal one or do I have to return the one received and place another order?

I'm sorry, but I really don't know. On your Order Page you'll see Return/Refund to the right of the Stopper. Try that and see what they say. Good Luck!