LORACLove, Lust and Lace Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil Set

Creamy smudge-proof eyeliners. The pigmentation is fantastic. I tried rubbing my finger across the swatches 10 times, and only the glitter moved.The pencils twist up so you don't need to fiddle with an annoying pencil sharpener. The silver and gold colors look amazing on the lower lash line.I would say the only downside is that the glittery colors irritated my eyes. The glitter got in my glands between my eyelashes. I would only wear these pencils on special occasions. My eyes were aching and red for a day after wearing this product. And be sure to take your makeup off so you don't get a stye. Also do not apply the on your waterline or near your tear duct.

I will NEVER use another eyeliner ever again because LORAC eyeliner is just freaking AMAZING!! When you put on it takes about 30 seconds to set and then you have a “No Smudge” Eyeliner! SERIOUSLY! Plus, it has a nice little sparkle in it. It goes on so soft and easy. I have never had so many compliments on my makeup since I started using LORAC Violet Eyeliner for my daily makeup and when I have a special night out with my husband I use one of the eyeliners from this package from LORAC as it has a more nightlife feeling to it. I have green eyes with gold flecks so I like to use the gold eyeliner for my special nights out with my husband.You won’t find a better eyeliner out on the market today! Take my word for it. I have been using top of the line products for years and this is the best one out there hands down!

tldr: I Love these liners.There is not a dud in this set.All of the colors are vibrant and smugde proof. Once they dry (about 1 minute after application) they DO NOT MOVE. I had to scrub the swatches with soap and water to remove them. One thing of note, the gold and silver are very glittery, so much so that there is a bit of glitter fallout from them.I have fairly sensitive eyes and had no irritation from any of the colors.They are of a substantial weight, the consistency is crayon like, twist up and a tiny sharpener pulls out of the bottom of the tube. There is a little over an inch of product in the pencil and sharpening has very minimal waste.

I normally love Lorac liner and ordered this set since it was less expensive than a single liner. I bought it mainly for the black, which was the one I had problems with. It just didn't want to go on well. I had to go over and over and over just to get a light line, so I even tried prepping it on paper (on which it wrote just fine) but that really didn't help it apply any better on my lid. Today I gave up and used the black sparkle one that has glitter in it. I'm not a fan of the glitter but this one really went on easily and smoothly. I don't have any use for the gold and silver liners so I'll give those away. Just frustrated that the one I really needed just didn't go on more than just a light greyish line.

I have been using this Lorac product for about 6 months now. I LOVED IT until I bought these. I got one as a trial in a makeup club I belong to. I said yes, finally a pencil that went on eyelids easily!! I ordered this set and they were like crayons trying to put on. It was like it was dried up or something. They would not even write on paper.....Too Bad....I thought I had finally found great pencil. Too much trouble researching etc on how to send back so I threw them away.

Hope springs eternal. Only 2 of the pencils were soft enough to apply. I lost patience with the other two and tossed them out as soon as I saw how hard they were. But after using many eye pencils through the years I knew I could expect disappointments and this was no surprise. This being said, the two pencils I did keep are wonderful, glide on smoothly and last all day!

These are terrible... I try to use them and they drag and do not draw a nice line. I would not recommend purchasing these because they are so difficult to use and a real disappointment.

The first time I purchased all of them were too dry or broken. The last one I ordered all but the black one was usable. The black was too dry and could not be applied. Making my purchase $10 each for 3 that worked instead of 4.