Crazy Aaron’s Lost Treasure Guardians Thinking Putty - Mini Tin (4 Pack) - Made in USA

My kids loved this 4 pack of “mystery slime.” Each with a different character and color included. Fun surprise for each kid with this variety. Great stocking stuffer!

I work with autistic children, and this has been a great thing to fidget with. They are pretty and stretchy and not sticky. The only problem I’ve had is the containers can be hard to open at times.

I'm a neurodivergent adult and this is my first experience with Crazy Aaron's putty. I love it! The brand is a bit expensive for me, in general, so I got the minis in a pack to try several different kinds. They all feel awesome in my hands--very cool consistency--without being sticky and without getting color or glitter everywhere. It was so much fun to be surprised with each type, too! I got 2 common, 1 uncommon, and 1 rare! I'm happy with that combo and they're all very pretty, too--bonus points. I'll be back for more putty when there's a sale.

Kids always enjoy the Aaron putties. Just wish they ran cheaper but they're expensive everywhere. Oh well.

These are great for fidgety hands. I like to play with the putty while I'm doing my talk therapy! Also they're pretty.

The Story 5/31/25 I originally got this because I wanted to try out Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty without committing to a standard size tin. I thought getting this sampler pack would be a great test and I liked the idea of getting the adorable collectible charms! I think the design is clever with the peelable label so that it can either remain a mystery but after there's a way to differentiate them. I agree with some of the reviewers who said that the tins can be difficult to open - especially since these are small and hard to hold. I had 1 that took me about an hour of working it before it opened but the other 3 were fine. They seem good quality, inventive, and fun. I enjoyed them so much I decided to get 2 more packs to try to collect all the charms. Very disappointed since the 2 other packs were exactly the same as my first one, so I have 3x my original 4 charms. 1/2 of the tins I got this time (4/8) were difficult to open, but nowhere near as difficult as the one from my first batch. The Good - good quality in production and design of the mystery putty and tins - reasonable price - good way to try different types - adorable charms - mystery aspect is exciting - great gifts or stocking stuffers The Bad - it's frustrating and disheartening that some of the tins can be (very) difficult to open - it seems that the tins are not really randomized at all, since I got exact triplicates for all 3 batches that I ordered I would 10/10 recommend getting a set but if you're looking to collect, be wary of spending too much. If even a few in each batch were different I'd chalk it up to chance and the nature of the blind boxes, but since they were all 100% the same, I think it's rigged actually.

Super bummed, ordered these as gifts for Christmas and they were all defective. Rock hard and unusable. Do not buy from here!

This is so much fun on so many levels. I did get a duplicate, however love the thrill of not knowing what you will be given. The charms are really cute and perfectly matched with the putty! Love the small tins that can be place in and around so you will have a play toy at reach...always. Nope, I’m not a kid and extremely love playing with this THINKING PUTTY as an artist and designer. Seriously helps with ever aspect of creativity! Highly Recommended for Everyone!