Lord & Berry Back in Brown Mascara, Mascara Volume and Length, Long Lasting, Tubing mascara No Smudging, Clumping, Vagan & Cruelty Free, Deep Brown

I have been using Lord & Berry MasCare for the past year. It outperforms several other mascaras I had used in the past, including Lancome Definicils, Origins Fringe Benefits, and Body Shop Super Volume. It goes on cleanly without clumps, looks natural, absolutely stays in place without migrating to the lower lid (which is where all of the aforementioned mascaras eventually end up on me), and easily comes off without a lot of rubbing (using a gentle eye makeup remover). I don't see this brand a lot...I first discovered it at a cool little boutique drugstore in midtown Manhattan. Hopefully this company stays around.

I was excited to try this mascara, but when I received it, it looked used! The case had scratches and the black was worn down in spots. I returned it without using it because I was afraid what was in the tube was not the real product and could potentially be bad. And there's no way I'd want that near my eyes or on my lashes.

One of the best Mascaras I've tried!

This is probably a good product but with my short stumpy lashes it doesn't work for me.

It does go on nicely and helps lashes look full - but sadly it both flakes easily and black smudging starts appearing under eyes. Not a good look :).