Nuts ‘N More Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Spread - High Protein, Low Carb, Low Sugar, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, All-Natural Nut Butter Snack (15oz Jar)

I roginallt found this at my grocery store. As a gym girly, I eye protein food products. Noticed this one in the peanut butter section and grabbed it to try. YUMMMMM. I got the birthday cake flavor. I scooped 2 heaping spoon fulls and put on a plate, garnished the nut butter with some dark chocolate syrup and sliced some apples. Swirled an apple slice into it and I have been addicted ever since! I tried to find it again but it was sold out, opted for the brown sugar flavor (another flavor I like) but it was nasty 🤢 I didn’t like it at all’! Took to Amazon, now we’re here 😊 Alreasy purchased a second tub after finishing this one with a spoon 🥄 🤭 Also, just like the store bought one, this one came sealed with the white lid underneath the white outer lid. They start out oily, this one’s easy to mix the oil with the spoon. I had to microwave the brown sugar to stir it, with a lot of grunt, to not much avail as it’s still not completely stirred to perfect. I just mixed chocolate with the brown sugar to stomach the taste. The chocolate with this one tastes like chocolate cake very slightly, without tastes like peanut butter cookies 🍪

I had very high expectations for this stuff and I was hoping that I could make it a daily addition to my shakes, but like others have said, the new formula is garbage...The texture is very gritty and seems as though they mixed it with some extremely cheap whey protein. I really had hoped for more, but this thing went into the trash as soon as I got it.8/11/16 **Update**I was contacted by Nuts 'N More in regards to my review and they offered to send me a new shipment of their new formula. The new formula was 100% better than the previous version and has become a daily addition to my morning shake. When the order arrived I noticed that some separation had occurred because the top portion was VERY salty, but a good stir quickly changed things. The taste is such a drastic difference in comparison to their old formula. Less gritty and tastes like it was made with higher quality protein and actually tastes how I felt cookie butter should taste.I greatly appreciate them reaching out to me and I believe that is how customer service should be handled by every company. Thank you Nuts 'N More team.2/22/17 **Update**Since my review is getting more attention than I had anticipated I thought I would provide another update on this stuff. I am still using this on a near every day basis. I've found that adding a spoonful to a protein shake or a bowl of oatmeal is a great way add some additional protein and a wonderful flavor. I've tried a few of their other flavors and still have not found one that I liked more than the cookie butter.

It's true that you have to stir it, but that's just nature. This is a high quality, low sugar, high protein, great tasting treat with a nice texture and consistency once it's stirred. I love this one and the cinnamon raisin. Both are gluten free varieties.

I never write reviews. Mostly because I feel bad and don't want to hurt the business with a negative review.However, this is an exception. This product is absolutely DISGUSTING. It arrived oil spilling from jars, allover the amazon package. Very messy to clean from the start without even having opening the jar.Still I was optimistic.....I had seen so many AWESOME reviews that surely it had to be lovely.I opened the jars and what stared me back was 1.5 inches of THICK oil. Okay No problem... ill stir and mix it in. IT DOES NOT mix easily. I mean I struggled, "the protein spread" AKA cement was like caked like cement to the bottom of the jar. Trying to mix it was nearly impossible after abut 20 soemthing minutes, oil now spilling over sides of jars and counter I was frustrated. It was as mixed as it would ever get.So now, still optimistic lets taste it.I bought two jars:1-Choc Chip Cookie Dough2- Birthday cakeThey taste nothing like what was advertised. The flavor profiles did not taste like birthday cake or cookie dough. It tasted like a strange artificial thick, pasty spread. Its chalky, leaves a very strong after taste that leaves little to be desired.I thought it was just me.... My younger sister came to visit me with some of her college aged girl friends. They saw the jars and asked me about it. I feel guilty to admit this.. but I happily and enthusiastically encouraged them to try a BIG spoonful each. Needless to say they were Not pleased with what they tasted. Two of the girls spit it out in my kitchen sink. At least one girl was discreet and spit it into a paper towel. Needless to say the visit didn't get off on a great foot.

Depending on flavor, this might be the best PB that ever crossed my lips! Seriously good. It's a little drippy, which is good to stir up the oil and the chips, etc...this stuff might not last the week. It's that good!Here's my thoughts on the flavors I've tried so far:1) Salted caramel. Pretty good! No chips or whatnot in this one, but tasty.2) Chocolate chip- Now my fav! My chips melted and were at the bottom, so I gave it a good stir and oh wow.3) White chocolate and Pretzel: 2nd runner up and really good. YUM!4) I finally ordered the PB cup one, tastes good- but I live in Florida, and it arrived totally melted. So, the little cups were completely gone. I'm sure I would have loved them...5) My 2nd least favorite is Cookie Butter. It's just okay, sort of an odd taste to it.6) and finally, my least favorite is Birthday cake. There's an almond extract type of flavor, I'm guessing to emulate "cake", but I hate almond extract. Literally hate it...and even if it's not in there, it tastes like it is. I ended up throwing this one away.If you are on the fence, try the chocolate chip one first and go from there!