Best Bully SticksThick 6 Inch Bully Sticks for Dogs - 5 Count (Pack of 1) - Natural, Grass-Fed Beef, Single Ingredient, Grain and Rawhide Free - Large Breeds

Excellent chew for medium size dogs. Guaranteed to keep them busy for a few hours. Expensive for a daily chew if you have multiple dogs but when you need it you need it. Guests, hotels, new puppies, etcThere is the usual bully stick odor.

Okay, first thing you should know about these: they smell NASTY. All bully sticks will smell to some degree (you can buy some that are less smelly but even those ones will still have a faint scent) but these are far and away the WORST smelling brand of bully sticks I've tried. I seriously cannot express how gross these things smell without being offensive.Now, that being said, I'm still giving these 5 stars, because my pup (9 month old German Shepherd/husky mix) loves these bully sticks (maybe because they smell so bad, who knows the mind of a dog). I get the thick kind because they last the longest. These days, he can chew threw them pretty fast, but I've been getting them for him for months and when he was smaller they would easily last hours. Since he got his big boy teeth they don't last as long but to be fair, not much really can stand up to those big teeth and powerful jaws anymore without being a danger. I am still pleased with how long they do last (it would probably take him about 30 minutes or so to chew through a whole one but luckily his attention span isn't that long). The price is also way cheaper than the big box pet stores, who want twice as much for half the amount of sticks.So, given that my puppy loves these, they last a decent amount of time, and they are the best price point for bully sticks I've found, I'm giving them 5 stars. But just to reiterate THEY SMELL COMPLETELY AWFUL. Some batches are a bit better but the last 2 packs I've gotten have almost made me gag when opening because of how horrible they are. Hope my puppy knows how much I love him....

My super chewer mini pin LOVES these. It is the highlight of her day when she gets one. They do not have an offensive smell. The size is good for my 13 pound dog. I assume she likes the taste! She also does not have any stomach issues after chewing them which is a plus!

Dog loves these but we call them stinky bones cause they do smell.

This time they were very well done and my dog only would eat two out of 5!!very disappointedHe usually loves them and they are his favorite. It’s disappointing because they are expensive when he won’t eat some of them. Usually they are great

I had been reading reviews of other products before picking this one, and I saw that a common complaint was in the variability of the sizes of sticks in some of the other products. I've gotten a couple packages of this one, and haven't had any problems so far. They seem to all be relatively the same length, and although the thickness may vary slightly, it's not drastic.My 4-month old Border Collie/Australian Shepherd can chew through a lot (I've never had a dog that has just gnawed through rope toy knots like he does, before). Now, when he's in a particularly focused gnawing mood, I give him a bully sick for about 10 minutes, and he really zones out and chews hard until I have him trade it back in (I give him a small treat for relinquishing this one, so that he does it voluntarily). It seems to satisfy his need to chew very well.He can usually get several good 10-minute chew sessions in on one stick, before it gets too short. I've also just ordered a bully stick holder, though, because there have been a couple times when I've thought it was plenty long enough, but he's still swallowed it toward the end of the 10 minutes. I would rather him be able to get more chewing time out of each of them, without worrying about him choking on a large piece.I know that another complaint I've seen/heard a lot about bully sticks is the smell of them. I don't love the smell of it, because I dislike most smells/scents, but it isn't more offensive to my nose than most other bacon/beef scented treats/toys. I only let my puppy chew on it while he's in his crate, and if he brings it out of there before the timer goes off, he has to trade it in early. So, any smell is pretty well contained to there, and isn't getting all over the carpet in random places. (I don't smell it when he isn't actively chewing on it.) The trade-off of the productive chewing, instead of on me, or other non dog toys, vastly outweighs my distaste for the odor.

Product is ok. My dog preferred other treats over this one.

I’ve ordered many different styles of bulky sticks seem this brand. Sometimes they’re right on, and sometimes not so much. This recent delivery I specifically ordered this THICK version because my pup likes them when they’re big around. But these were like a standard bulky, not thick or big around at all. We’ll keep them because in her eyes, all bully’s are good. But next time I may try another brand. One key thing this pup mom really liked is that they were NOT stinky at all. But that’s another bit or miss, so have been in the past. I just wish the brand was more consistent so I could know what I’m getting. Overall great quality too.