NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPJumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Cottage Cheese (Silver)

This last really long and is super good for makeup. It’s not hard to wash off but it last one and it’s good quality for such a cheap price. Would definitely recommend and buy again!!

Goes on well and good value for the cost.

I bought the cottage cheese color, hoping that it would be light enough, but would show up to use on my waterline. I have very sensitive eyes so I wanted to see if this would work on the waterline for me but unfortunately it was to share to even show up. However, being used in the corner of the eye as a highlight, it’s the perfect color! so I will purchase the milk next and see if that will work for my waterline but I do recommend the cottage cheese for any type of a highlight color on the eyes or face or eyebrow. The only down part is that you have to sharpen these which I absolutely hate sharpening a pencil I wish it was just automatic .

I started purchasing NYX cosmetics from time-to-time after being hooked on high-end (overpriced) cosmetics for years. I've found many of their products are just as good, some are better!I originally bought this for my water line. It is a subtle color that works beautifully on the waterline to open up your eyes and give you a beautiful bright look.In addition, I've used this as a highlighter eye shadow under my brows and on my eyelids. It is creamy and has beautiful coverage. The best part, it doesn't crease and melt!I have oily skin and do add a finishing spray after application.I've purchased several more pigmented colors and love them all.Note, this is a jumbo stick, it doesn't twist up, so you need to sharpen it.Great product for the price... try it!

I love this product. I use cottage cheese and Frappuccino on days I want a no makeup look that’s quick. It gives a nice shimmer, dewy look without giving too much shimmer. After seeing a ton of reviews complaining it doesn’t twist up or that you only get a small amount I had to leave a review and says that YOU SHARPEN IT!! It does sharpen! You will need a decent sharpener too. Not all sharpeners are created equal and if you don’t have a good one all it will do is destroy your pencils of any kind and waste product. NYX makes a sharpener that fits this pencil. I am currently using a different brand and it’s working well but I’m gonna go ahead and get the NYX one as too. It doesn’t twist up, it doesn’t push up, you sharpen it. It says in one of the slides for the product description. NYX needs to make that more clear so people will know and not throw out their product.

This review is for "Cottage Cheese", which is a shimmery white.About me: 40 something, barely emerging fine lines (so far so good!), dry, rosacea prone skin. Sensitive eyes. Dark hair, dark eyes, fair skin (alabaster).I love jumbo eye pencils. I think they are great way to add some color- whether all over lid, or as an eye liner. Creamy eye pencils just make it easy to quickly apply some color without spending much time doing so. I love the creamy aspect to jumbo eye pencils, and I find that they rarely irritate my sensitive eyes. I usually use 100% Pure brand for creamy eye pencils, but they have done away with them. So I have been trying out different brands as I find them. I bought a few colors from this collection, as the add on price made it easy and budget friendly to do so.I love white or super light eye color. My skin is fair, cool, and slightly pink. This is a great color if you like a very soft, shimmery white. It adds just a little shimmer with a hint of white. I thought it was going to be my go-to cream pencil as I really like to just take a quick swipe of white to my lids to perk them up before heading out the door. The color is nice, but it doesn't quite stand out, like it is almost similar to my skin tone. I have applied it directly to my skin, and I have used it with a primer and powder. I'd say it definitely needs the latter for staying power.Sadly, the product makes my eyes feel weird after a short period of time. Kinda tired feeling, kinda itchy.. meh.While application is creamy, it does tug a little on the skin. I find myself applying it then smoothing it out with my finger as gently as possible. It doesn't apply strong enough to create a visible line. So if you wanted to use it as a defined eye liner, you may not be successful in doing so. I also have a darker color which I use this for, and it really just applies a soft sweep of color rather than a line. I think these are best as an eyes shadow, or as a highlighter.As for container.. so once you get through the exposed product, you can only reach more of it by sharpening it. It really could have a turn base to move product up rather than people having to use a large sharpener to cut away at the hard casing. Sharpening is fine if the material around the product is conducive to easy sharpening without losing integrity of product or patience of user. This material is not a great choice for that.

This really highlights my eyes!

Really nice but you need a big sharpener for it.